So many great choices, but Gargoyles gets my vote. That scared the hell out of me when I was a little kid. That pre-credits intro, the musical score, and the first gargoyle attack sealed the deal for me many years ago. Still watch the dvd at least three times a year. Two years ago, I visited Carlsbad Caverns in New Mexico where this was filmed. I will never ever tire of this early Stan Winston creature feature. Very close behind Gargoyles for me would be The Night Stalker/Night Strangler and Don't Be Afraid of the Dark. Kolchak is an icon, what more needs to be said? Don't Be Afraid of the Dark is still scary over thirty years later. Neither are classic, but Devil Dog: Hound of Hell and Kiss Meets the Phantom of the Park are both entertaining and worthy of repeat visits. Trilogy of Terror is overrated as a whole. The third story is great, but the first two are ponderous in comparison.