Black Christmas

Discussion in 'High Def' started by rhett, Nov 10, 2008.

  1. rhett

    rhett Administrator

    Joined:
    Jul 30, 2000
    Messages:
    9,395
    Likes Received:
    45
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Canada
    [​IMG]


    [​IMG] Reviewer: Rhett
    Review Date: November 10, 2008

    Released by: Anchor Bay
    Release date: 12/02/2008
    MSRP: CAD $36.98
    Format: Blu-ray
    Region A, NTSC
    1080p MPEG-4 AVC
    Widescreen 1.78:1 | 16x9: Yes
    1974


    inline ImageMuch has been made of Anchor Bay’s endless re-releasing of key titles like Halloween or The Evil Dead. Is it ironic, then, that they are finally partnering with Canadian company Critical Mass to bring out possibly the only other film with more re-releases than Halloween, Black Christmas? The Bob Clark slasher template maker is now on its fourth official release, although most infuriating of all, it never seems to get more definitive – just definitely more different. I just first we should preface this review for the new Blu-ray disc with a little primer on what’s out there and why it’s important.

    inline ImageBlack Christmas first came out inconspicuously in Canada for its 25th anniversary in 1999. It has two very short interviews with John Saxon that are not on current editions. It remains relevant today, as well, because of the aspect ratio, which continues to remain on contestation. The 1999 release is open matte, and while some sequences, like the iconic ending, are more effective in full, many, like the group phone call, are victim to a creeping boom mic. A boom wouldn’t have made it into the final cut, right? So out then came a new special edition from Critical Mass in 2002. This time the ratio was 1.66:1 non-anamorphic, and while the boom was gone, the end still wasn’t quite right. What this release did have, though, was a multitude of stellar extras, including audio commentaries, interviews and a return to the original location. No matter how good the extras, though, the aspect ratio concerns still needed to be addressed.

    Somerville House, this time a US outfit, decided to try and finally provide a definitive release. Their 2006 disc was 1.85:1 anamorphic, finally the aspect ratio of the North American cinemas it was made for, and it had a number of new extras including advertised lost scenes. Still, fans balked at the new yellow hue and the lack of extras from the original release.

    Well, here we are in 2008, just in time for another Christmas season, and here’s yet another trip to Agnes’ well. Within weeks of each other, both Anchor Bay (through Critical Mass) and Somerville House are releasing Blu-rays of this most celebrated of Christmas horror films. Are the extras the same? Have the colors been fixed? How about that new resolution? Let’s unravel the bow on this yuletide classic and get some answers.

    The Story

    inline ImageIt’s the holiday season in Bedford as a group of sorority girls prepare to celebrate the festivities. Included in such revelry is drinking and socializing, as the sorority girls throw a little party. Unbeknownst to them however, lurks an uninvited guest. Neurotically creeping his way around the exterior of the sorority house, the unnamed prowler makes his way into the house through the upper window. Meanwhile, Jess (played by the gorgeous Olivia Hussey), Barb (Margot Kidder), the outspoken drunk of the group, and the rest of the girls mingle in the living room.

    inline ImageThings take a blacker turn when the house begins receiving obscene phone calls from the intruder. After a series of high pitched shrills and squeals, the prowler then informs Barb that he is going to kill her. Still upset from the phone call, Clare (Lynne Griffin) goes upstairs to finish packing only to be suffocated by the psychotic intruder. While this happens, the compulsively drunken house mother, Mrs. Mac (Marian Waldman) provides some much needed comic relief as she searches for alcohol while the girls worry. Hours later, Clare’s father and the rest of the girls are unable to find her, a search is called on by the police, led by Lieutenant Fuller (John Saxon), but to little success.

    inline ImageAs the search continues, so does the brutal and disturbing phone calls to the sorority house. Full of fright, the intelligent and wholesome Jess Bradford gets her phone tapped by the police to find the whereabouts of the killer. After numerous calls, the police finally determine that the calls are coming from inside the house (a plot point that would be stolen 5 years later in When A Stranger Calls). As if Jess’ night could not get any worse, she must also deal with the fact that she is pregnant and that her aggressive boyfriend Peter (Keir Dullea) is angered over her desire to abort the baby.

    Jess, now knowing that her friends have been slain and that a killer lurks within her house, must play a cat and mouse game in order to survive the austere night. Not exactly your typical perennial Christmas favorite, eh?

    inline ImageIt’s easy to see the film’s connections to Halloween and superficially try to split hairs. They are both based around a holiday! They both use the first person perspective! They both have muffled phone calls! But after all these years, what makes the film stand out from the pack is precisely what it doesn’t have in common with the other films in the slasher genre. Black Christmas is a masterpiece of subtlety. It’s quiet when most films are loud, it’s funny when most films are scrambling for a jolt and it’s ambiguous when other films start giving answers. Scares are never choreographed, but instead come out of a mounting fear that what is unfolding is not guided by any sense of convention or plot. Bob Clark stated that he never was a huge fan of movies before becoming a filmmaker, and it figures, because Black Christmas does not play out like a conventional film.

    inline ImageThe first case in point – the killer. While other films have no doubt experimented with the first person, or deprivation of explanation or identification, none have done it with the experimental resolve done by Black Christmas. You know you’re in for trouble right from the start when the wide angel camera starts literally climbing up the porch lattice. The first person visuals are still incredibly enveloping and powerful, and those view shadowed glimpses of “Billy” have all become iconic in themselves. Yet, Clark does not rely on mere anonymity for his scares, like lesser examples like The Strangers. The unknown is not necessarily scary in itself. It’s the potential chaos that can exist behind normalcy that is truly what drives humanity’s fear of the dark. Bob Clark knows this, and he does what almost nobody else has been able to do by giving the unknown a character that is both abstract enough that it can never be empathized with, but material enough that it can be understood.

    inline ImageBilly, surely one of the greats of all cinema villains, is crazy like no other. We understand that he’s disturbed, that he’s done something to this “Agnes”, and that he’s several, several cards short of a full deck. That’s it. Rather than rely on the usual conventions of having detectives spout exposition about an escaped convicts history, or the heroes stopping off at the library to look through news clippings, Bob Clark is much more clever to instead rely on the calamity of the present. Clark relies almost entirely on the sound design to develop character, and those from the hip tourette’s telephone calls and infinitely more effective than any plot point could ever be. Like if The Exorcist read Freud aloud, the calls are so unkempt and spontaneously shocking that they evoke an absolute chaos. Again, it’s not the unknown that is scary, but that the unknown can never be understood or reasoned with that truly gives Black Christmas its demented edge.

    inline ImageThe killer in Black Christmas may often be eruptive and abrasive, but the film itself is all the better for remaining quiet. So often in the film we find ourselves in silence, the camera circling around the house trying desperately to find something of shape or reason. Chaos may be happening throughout in the shadows, but in the Canadian documentarian tradition that guides the film, all Black Christmas can do is quietly search for answers. That the film includes Doug “Fellatio” McGrath, star of Canada’s internationally acclaimed ode to verite realism, Goin’ Down the Road only reinforces Clark’s commitment to subtlety. Jamie Lee Curtis became a scream queen in Halloween because of all of her high pitched histrionics, but contrary to popular belief, the heroine here is engrained in pleadingly problematic pregnant pauses.

    inline ImagePregnant pause is probably the wrong term to use in a film that so actively prods the hot button issue of abortion, but even that needs to be noted. There’s more than just storytelling that’s progressive with Black Christmas. The film is filled with strong women that tell the jokes and aren’t merely the brunt of them. McGrath’s famous fellatio scene retains its humor today not wholly because of the scenario, but because a powerful man of the law is being one-upped by a regular college girl. When they aren’t telling jokes they are dealing with pretty serious subject matter for a film that would make the usual drive-in rounds. Even in today’s entertainment, it seems there’s never a show where a woman just gives a definitive stance on abortion. It’s usually always noncommittal in fear it will polarize its audience.

    inline ImageClark cares about character though, and he always has. He’d rather offend someone by giving his character a negative trait than bore them by having them trot the middle of the road. Even his jovial films like Porky’s or A Christmas Story are wall to wall with personalities, and it’s because of his devotion to realistic characters that his films, and his characters, can so easily transition from comedy to horror or laughs to tears. It seems odd that a film as unsettling and terrifying as Black Christmas is so often very, very funny. That’s the Bob Clark way, though, and a prime example of how, again, Black Christmas is a film that can never be duplicated.

    inline ImageSure, many people say that most of the classics of cinema can never be duplicated, but that’s more or less hyperbole. Halloween is a masterpiece, but to say it hasn’t been xeroxed more times than its shooting script is a fabrication. It’s been duplicated, just never as good. Psycho has been duplicated, The Bird with the Crystal Plumage has been duplicated and Night of the Living Dead has been duplicated. Black Christmas, though, remains this teetering tightrope walk of calamity and calm foreboding that no film has ever come close to replicating. Of all the classics I own, Black Christmas is that one movie that is really just like nothing else before it or since. Even with all its re-releases over the years, I still feel as if I’m watching something new every time I pop it in. This was the first film I reviewed for the site back in 2001, and here I am again in 2008 still wondering why I haven’t seen another like it. Undeniably one of a handful of unrivalled classics on the medium, Black Christmas is a gift whatever time of year you watch it.

    Image Quality

    There was a mild stink made when Somerville’s recent Blu-ray was found to be only 11.9 GB when the average film is usually double that in high definition. Well, sorry to say, but Anchor Bay’s disc is exactly the same. What does this mean? Well, considering the high grain nature of the film (the naturalistic, minimal lighting necessitated faster, grainer film stocks) it is very tough to compress static portions of the frame. Granular imperfections are always dancing, and with a smaller bitrate like the one that is used here, those bits of grain turn into even more distracting bits of digital noise and artifacts. So as a result, this 1080p 1.78:1 MPEG-4 AVC transfer is much messier than it should be. Detail also suffers, with all of Olivia Hussey’s extreme close-ups looking flat because of the high compression.

    inline Image inline Imageinline Image
    Critical Mass 1999​
    Critical Mass 2002​
    Blu-ray​
    That’s the bad news. The good news, though, is that the colors here look much better than they have ever looked on any previous release. The overly yellow saturation of the previous Somerville benchmark has thankfully been corrected here, and like with the new Halloween Blu-ray, this is no doubt the most accurate and visually appealing way to see the film. The colors really pop, and considering the colorful Christmas theme, they get more than their fair share to throughout the runtime. The added resolution, even in its compressed state, still really makes a difference too. Textures on all those checked seventies clothing, depth on all those wide angle shots and the writing in all those books the headmaster hides her booze suddenly all come out with new life with the increased sharpness and larger image. Were it not for that distracting noise, this would be a beautiful transfer. It’s very clean, with only little white dots slightly showing throughout.

    inline Image inline Imageinline Image
    Critical Mass 1999​
    Critical Mass 2002​
    Blu-ray​
    Since I never was able to review the Somerville disc (blame that on Canadian customs), I’ll just add that their 1.78:1 framing here is without a doubt the final word on how the film should look. All the key scenes are without the problems from the previous ratios (too much head room, visible booms or cropped characters) and all the wide-angle action has an increased power the wider it gets. I’ve taken a few shots of the problematic scenes for comparison, but it’s clear – this is the ratio to see the film. If you’ve been holding on to your other discs purely for their ratio, then it’s time you give them out as Christmas presents. Black Christmas looks great in widescreen, and even with the grain and bitrate issues here on Blu-ray, HD is still very kind to this classic.

    Sound

    This disc, like the Somerville Blu-ray, retains all the audio tracks from the previous Somerville disc. The tracks are English Dolby Digital 5.1, English mono and French mono…how Canadian of them. The 5.1 track is alright. There are actually a few bits of Billy coming from speakers other than center, although it’s pretty few and far between. Since the film is one that relies on subtlety though, any surround showmanship would no doubt deflate the effectiveness of the original sound mix. The things that matter – the hiss and crackle evident in films of this age have been effectively removed while still retaining a semblance of depth to the sound. It’s still fairly flat, but remember…1974.

    Supplemental Material

    inline ImageOkay, so the film is only 11.9 GB and a single layer Blu-ray disc holds 25 GB, so we should be in for some serious supplements, right? Right? Err…wrong. Despite all the unused space on the disc, the extras that fans have been clamoring for from the second Critical Mass disc are sadly missing. That means we don’t get the two commentaries, one with the late Bob Clark and the other with John Saxon and Keir Dullea, the stellar half-hour retrospective documentary, the alternate title sequences (although they can be briefly glimpsed in the new documentary), the Dark Dreamers television episode with Saxon and a bunch of interviews with cast members like Keir Dullea. It’s a wonder why it wasn’t brought over, since Critical Mass is again responsible for this new Anchor Bay DVD. That said, the extras here still are no slouch.

    inline ImageWhat’s included are all the extras from the Somerville House DVD. That includes a twenty minute glimpse at the history of the film, narrated by John Saxon. It finally has Margot Kidder and Olivia Hussey, who were absent from previous releases, and includes again Art Hindle, Lynne Griffin (Claire), Doug McGrath and John Saxon. It’s a little fluffy and for fans of the film it doesn’t really have anything not already learned on the previous special edition, but it’s still a good sort of primer for the film itself. Then there are unabridged interviews with Hindle, Kidder and Hussey. Each of their segments runs around fifteen minutes a pop, and while their better bits already make it into the previous featurette, they still have some nice candid confessions. Kidder is the most fun, very liberal in spouting off against anything and everything, from conservative church groups to her own sex with the director antics on Sisters. It’s nice to finally here from Hussey, too, who contrary to popular belief is actually quite happy with the finished product. She still hasn’t seen Halloween, though.

    inline ImageThere’s also another twenty minute extra, this time a Q&A with John Saxon, Bob Clark and composer Carl Zittner [sic]. Filmed after a screening of the film, the three answer questions from fans with a good bit of laughs and particulars. Saxon explains how he was almost never cast, Zittrer talks about how they did the piano scene with Dullea, and Clark talks about all sorts of things from the identification of Billy to his influences. These sort of extras are always my favorite, and this one is no disappointment.

    inline ImageA few odds and ends round off this release, including the hyperboles that are the “recently uncovered original scenes”. What they are, really, are two takes from the film, but with slightly different audio stems. The first is Billy climbing outside, where now you can hear what the people inside are talking about. It’s filler, so who cares? The second is a very short alteration of Billy talking while the camera pans around the second floor, but you still can’t really make out what he’s saying. The French and English trailers that have been on every other release are also included.

    The pop-up Blu-ray menu is pretty blasé, but the opening menu screen is a fairly striking image. As far as packaging goes, the Anchor Bay disc looks much, much better than the Somerville disc, which uses their uninspired art from their previous DVD. The Anchor Bay disc has a taught rendering of a Christmas tree in blood, with the original poster image contained inside. Simple and effective. It should be noted that the advertised set of “4 Black Christmas cards and envelopes” is not included on this release as stated. Perhaps this is exclusive only to the Anchor Bay DVD?

    Final Thoughts

    inline ImageAlthough it may have inspired Halloween, Black Christmas remains so effective today because it is still so much more different than Carpenter’s film and all the imitations it spawned. The killer is no doubt the most fascinatingly ambiguous character in all of horror, and his crazy phone calls, and the subtle way Bob Clark captures his insanity, is still wholly unnerving. The Blu-ray image looks good, but is marred by a low bitrate and the inherent grain in the original master of the film. The sound is the same quality work that was featured on Somerville’s previous DVD. The extras, unfortunately, are also only from the Somerville DVD, so that means fans will have to still hang on to Critical Mass’s packed 2002 edition to retain all the meat regarding Black Christmas. The film has been released four times now, but I’m afraid it’s going to need another release before it can explicitly be called definitive. Still, for fans of the film, Christmas has come early and in high definition. Coal to you if you don’t like this Canadian Christmas classic.

    Rating

    [​IMG] Movie - A

    Image Quality - B*

    Sound - B+

    Supplements - B+


    *Because of the quality of the HD format, the clarity, resolution and color depth are inherently a major leap over DVD. Since any Blu-ray will naturally have better characteristics than DVDs, the rating is therefore only in comparison with other Blu-ray titles, rather than home video in general. So while a Blu-ray film may only get a C, it will likely be much better than a DVD with an A.

    Technical Info.
    • Color
    • Running time - 1 hour 38 minutes
    • Not Rated
    • 1 Disc
    • English Dolby Digital 5.1
    • English mono
    • French mono
    Supplements
    • Q&A with Bob Clark, John Saxon and Carl Zittrer
    • Retrospective featurette
    • Interviews with actors Olivia Hussey, Margot Kidder and Art Hindle
    • Alternate audio takes
    • Trailers
    Other Pictures

    [​IMG]
     
  2. Matt89

    Matt89 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Aug 13, 2004
    Messages:
    5,672
    Likes Received:
    944
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Toronto
    Seeing as how I never bought the original Somerville House disc, I'll still pick this up. Surely, if you sit back from your TV (like such is the case with upscaled DVDs) the image will appear more crisp due to the fact that you're not like 3 feet from your TV screen. Still, quite disappointing that the film is only 11.9 GB. (They never really can seem to get this film right, can they?)

    I'm surprised nothing was carried over from Critical Mass' earlier 2002 edition, seeing as how Anchor Bay collborated with Critical Mass to release this disc. Strange, but you can't win 'em all.
     
  3. Shannafey

    Shannafey Don't Monkey With Me!

    Joined:
    Jun 27, 2001
    Messages:
    6,941
    Likes Received:
    33
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    South Florida, But Far from the Hell that is Miami
    I recently picked up the 2002 release used for $10 and while I don't have Blu Ray yet, it looks like that version is the one to stick with!
     
  4. rhett

    rhett Administrator

    Joined:
    Jul 30, 2000
    Messages:
    9,395
    Likes Received:
    45
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Canada
    Well, for extras you need to have that disc, but for the film itself (which is the most important) the Somerville disc or this Blu-ray is definitely the way to go.
     
  5. Grim

    Grim Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2002
    Messages:
    7,667
    Likes Received:
    107
    Trophy Points:
    63
    Location:
    Baltimore, MD
    I can find the somerville disc on a lot of websites, but this disc seems to be non-existent to buy or pre-order. Anyone know where I can find it or am I just a moron?
     
  6. Matt89

    Matt89 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Aug 13, 2004
    Messages:
    5,672
    Likes Received:
    944
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Toronto
    No, you're just a moron. [​IMG]

    Amazon.ca
     
  7. anonymous

    anonymous New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2015
    Messages:
    35
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    The relatively small disc size makes me wonder if the movie and special features were originally designed/compressed for a single layer HD-DVD.
     
  8. BrokeNads

    BrokeNads New Member

    Joined:
    Nov 7, 2008
    Messages:
    249
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    I am enjoy this movie very much from over the year. I think is betters over all than Hallooween because is maybe stronger scripts but Halloween is more efective in atmospherics Black Christmas is more built up toward in the conclusion. I am original to buy dvd from 1999 with full screen version and I am like that one for the best version. I am happy with this but is only thing is it look like the quality like I am watch a tv show some grain and exetras. I am not to much for the blurays yet for this time because I am find many movies are more better with quality on original dvd and is only difference is more sharpness in blurays. New movies are good for the blurays but older movie when I see and compared is big disapointed on bluray.
     
  9. SickNick89

    SickNick89 Member

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2003
    Messages:
    505
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    West Chester, PA
    I went to pick up my Black Christmas blu-ray and was suprised to find it was a release from critical mass not anchor bay and had the same white 'screaming face' cover the 2006 CM DVD had not the new ' red X-mas tree' design. Whats the story? Are there actually 2 releases already?


    EDIT: Nevermind, just re-read the review.
     
  10. anonymous

    anonymous New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2015
    Messages:
    35
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    I didn't own this on SD-DVD and believe it or not, I'd never seen this flick before so I picked it up. It looks terrible but that's fine. Another thing i noticed is that the left hand side of the frame appears to be darker in some of the shadowy scenes. Anyone else notice this. It might be on the right as well but the left is where I continually noticed it. At fist I thought it was just a camera effect they were using at the first if the movie but the darkness continues throughout the film.
     
  11. It's me Billy

    It's me Billy New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2004
    Messages:
    590
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    It's disappointing that the BD is compressed at such a high rate, but I don't think the image looks terrible by any means. Maybe one day they'll find the original negative and get it right by including a pristine new transfer with a higher bitrate, a corrected 5.1 soundtrack (along with the original mono), and all of the extras from the 2002 CE DVD and the 2006 SE DVD/2008 DVD & BD.

    Until then, this will do nicely.

    My Black Christmas (1974 and 2006) DVD, HD DVD, and Blu-ray Disc Collection:

    Black Christmas (1974) 2002 Collector's Edition DVD (w/ original 1974 cover art)

    Black Christmas (1974) 2008 Canadian DVD (Critical Mass/Anchor Bay, 'Red X-Mas tree' cover)

    Black Christmas (1974) 2008 Canadian Blu-ray Disc (Critical Mass/Anchor Bay, 'Red X-Mas tree' cover)

    Black Christmas (2006) 2007 Unrated DVD

    Black Christmas (2006) 2007 Unrated HD DVD

    Black Christmas (2006) 2008 Canadian Blu-ray Disc
     
  12. anonymous

    anonymous New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 13, 2015
    Messages:
    35
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    i like this movie and i bought it on blu. It looks pretty good. This film is so strange, I liked it, but it took awhile to realize i liked it. It's a very different kind of classic
     
  13. JGrendel

    JGrendel New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2010
    Messages:
    1,888
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Location:
    Olds Alberta Canada
    I love this movie but I just find it funny that Bob Clark also did Porky's.
     
  14. old-boo-radley

    old-boo-radley They stay the same age...

    Joined:
    Feb 26, 2004
    Messages:
    1,869
    Likes Received:
    36
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Saskatchewan
    Porky's is basically God's gift to film, Grendel! No shame in a good ol' Canadian teen sex comedy!
     
  15. JGrendel

    JGrendel New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2010
    Messages:
    1,888
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Location:
    Olds Alberta Canada
    Hey I've got nothing against Porky's I own all three of them, it's just he went from doing this intense slasher to doing a sex comedy it makes me wonder if that was intentional or just a weird twist of fate.
     
  16. JGrendel

    JGrendel New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2010
    Messages:
    1,888
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Location:
    Olds Alberta Canada
    Okay & can anyone clear this up for me, I was able to snag a sommerville version of the Blu-ray. But what is the difference from that one & this one?
     
  17. It's me Billy

    It's me Billy New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2004
    Messages:
    590
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    The only difference is the cover art.
     
  18. JGrendel

    JGrendel New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2010
    Messages:
    1,888
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    0
    Location:
    Olds Alberta Canada
    Good to know thanks.
     

Share This Page