PDA

View Full Version : Your Top 10 Asian Films - Let the Grading Begin!


DVD Connoisseur
06-08-2003, 01:39 AM
In Round One, the search for the 10 most popular Asian films on this forum revealed the following movies (in alphabetical order):

Audition
Battle Royale
Evil Dead Trap
The Eye
Ichi The Killer
Kairo
The Ring
Tell Me Something
The Untold Story
Uzumaki

The time has come to rank them....10 points for your favourite, 9 points for your second favourite, etc. If you haven't seen a film, please give it a 0.

Let the scoring start....

DVD Connoisseur
06-08-2003, 01:46 AM
My scoring would be as follows (this is a toughie):

Audition - 10
Ichi The Killer - 9
Evil Dead Trap - 8
Battle Royale - 7
The Ring - 6
The Eye - 5
Tell Me Something - 4
The Untold Story - 3
Uzumaki - 2
Kairo - 0 (Haven't caught this one yet...)

dvdasia62
06-08-2003, 03:02 AM
Audition - 9
Battle Royale - 1
Evil Dead Trap - 6
The Eye - 10
Ichi The Killer - 0 (haven't seen it)
Kairo - 8
The Ring - 5
Tell Me Something - 9
The Untold Story - 1
Uzumaki - 5

2D4EVER
06-08-2003, 03:49 AM
Audition 10
Kairo 9
The Ring 8
Ichi The Killer 7
Tell Me Something 6
The Eye 5
Evil Dead Trap 4
Battle Royale 0
The Untold Story 0
Uzumaki 0

Just saw Kairo tonight. Fucking great. :D Need to see Battle Royale and Uzumaki soon.

mcchrist
06-08-2003, 06:50 AM
Battle Royale - 10
The Untold Story - 9
The Ring - 8
Evil Dead Trap - 7
Audition - 6

The Eye - 0
Ichi The Killer - 0
Kairo - 0
Tell Me Something - 0
Uzumaki - 0

Deaddevilman
06-08-2003, 07:04 AM
Audition - 8
Battle Royale - 7
Evil Dead Trap - 6
The Eye - 0
Ichi The Killer - 0
Kairo - 1
The Ring - 5
Tell Me Something - 9
The Untold Story - 10
Uzumaki - 4

aoiookami
06-08-2003, 11:14 AM
Audition 9
Battle Royale 10
Evil Dead Trap 0
The Eye 8
Ichi The Killer 6
Kairo 0
The Ring 7
Tell Me Something 0
The Untold Story 0
Uzumaki 5

Evil Disco Guy
06-09-2003, 06:07 PM
Audition - 10
Battle Royale - 9
Evil Dead Trap - 4
The Eye - 3
Ichi The Killer - 8
Kairo - 2
The Ring - 7
Tell Me Something - 1
The Untold Story - 6
Uzumaki - 5

mafianinja
06-13-2003, 04:48 AM
Audition -7
Battle Royale -8
Evil Dead Trap -5
The Eye -2
Ichi The Killer -10
Kairo -0 not seen
The Ring -6
Tell Me Something -3
The Untold Story -4
Uzumaki -9

Disco Stu
06-13-2003, 05:16 AM
Audition 2
Battle Royale 10
Evil Dead Trap 4
The Eye 6
Ichi The Killer 10
Kairo 10
The Ring 6
Tell Me Something 4
The Untold Story 3
Uzumaki 0


Edited to add:

Oops I realized my error. I just gave them ratings on my personal feelings about them, Uzumaki being the only one I haven't seen.

I guess the order would be

#1 Battle Royale
#2 Kairo
#3 Ichi the Killer
a distant #4 The Ring
#5 The Eye
#6 Tell Me Something
#7 Evil Dead Trap
#8 The Untold Story
#9 Audition

napalm68
06-13-2003, 11:38 AM
Dunno if I can come up with 10, but:

#1 Kairo
#2 Ichi the Killer
#3 Hypnosis
#4 Ring
#5 Battle Royale
#6 The Eye
#7 Audition
#8 Ring 2

For the ones you have listed:
#6 Audition
#4 Battle Royale
??? Evil Dead Trap
#5 The Eye
#2 Ichi The Killer
#1 Kairo
#3 The Ring
??? Tell Me Something
??? The Untold Story
??? Uzumaki

slinker
06-14-2003, 07:00 PM
Audition +9
Battle Royale +9
Evil Dead Trap +6
The Eye +7
Ichi The Killer +9
Kairo +9
The Ring +8
Tell Me Something 0
The Untold Story +7
Uzumaki +8

Erg0n
06-17-2003, 08:34 AM
The Ring 10
Audition 9
Evil Dead Trap 8
Uzumaki 7

The rest i've never seen. I don't know if my votes would count.

The Chaostar
06-23-2003, 04:56 AM
Audition 10
Battle Royale 9
Evil Dead Trap 7
The Eye 8
Ichi The Killer 7
Kairo 8
The Ring 9

DVD Connoisseur
06-23-2003, 06:13 PM
Thanks for all your votes...I'll keep "the lines open" 'til the weekend and then post the results.

Azmodan
06-23-2003, 06:16 PM
Ichi The Killer - 10
Ringu - 10
The Eye - 8
Battle Royale - 8
Ring 0: Birthday - 7
Ring 2 - 6
Wild Zero - 6
Audition - 5

Wermode
06-24-2003, 10:02 AM
Audition-9
Battle Royale-6
Evil Dead Trap-8
The Eye-2
Ichi The Killer-5
Kairo-4
The Ring-10
Tell Me Something-3
The Untold Story-1
Uzumaki-7

DVD Connoisseur
07-05-2003, 09:17 PM
And the results are.......

http://www.horrordvds.com/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&postid=136331#post136331