Of the listed options, I went with Prince of Darkness, although if I went strictly by "movie I most wanted on BD" and not overall release quality, I'd go with In the Mouth of Madness. We may have gotten the same old boring extras, but at least the movie is finally out in 1080p. Also, despite its issues, I have to give a shout out to Friday the 13th: The Complete Collection. All the movies look and sound good, and the only non-ported extras from the previous releases were two commentary tracks from the Manhattan set. If it weren't for the lack of unrated Jason Goes To Hell, I'd give the collection top marks.
I am Evil Homer. I am Evil Homer.