Silence of the Lambs CC vs. MGM

TobalRox · 10-28-2001, 10:32 PM

Just curious as to what some of the differences were. I looked at hte back and it seemed pretty identical, but I read somewhere that they were different deleted scenes and commentaries. Just curious as to whether or not I should get the MGM. Oh, and another thing, anamorphic doesn't really mean anything to me right now since i don't have a 16x9 TV

Dave · 10-28-2001, 10:52 PM

Here are MY thoughts on this [ sorry, Paff!

]:

When MGM announced this special edition, the question on everyone's mind was, "Should I still keep my Criterion disc?" True fans will actually want BOTH copies. The MGM version does provide a superior picture, and the documentaries are required viewing. But everyone should still locate the Criterion release if only for the commentary, as well as the serial killer essays on that disc. And I can attest that the Criterion laserdisc does have better sound. The bottom line is that it doesn't hurt to have more than one version of certain movies, and The Silence of the Lambs is one of the best. Get this disc.

TobalRox · 10-28-2001, 11:17 PM

I forgot to mention that I already have the Criterion... I just hate having two copies of movies... I did it with AoD but that was just because I missed out on the 2 disc set. Man, now that' sjust more money I gotta spend... damn DVDs

thanks for the info.

Paff · 10-29-2001, 12:14 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dave
Here are MY thoughts on this [ sorry, Paff! ]:

You know, I was about halfway through that when I started to notice it sounded familiar...

But it really doesn't hurt to have both. The docu on the new MGM disc is REALLY good. But you don't get the Criterion commentary, so definitely hold on to that disc too. If you're happy with the Criterion disc (and I know I am), you can wait for a sale or till you're in better financial straits to buy the MGM disc.

Get both.

KillerCannabis · 10-29-2001, 07:16 PM

I've got both versions of the film and I'd have to agree with the general consensus that if you're a fan of the film, you'll want both versions. The MGM disc will obviously be asy to find, however, the Criterion version is long out of print and could take some digging to find it. Maybe want to try e-bay, but youll probably end up paying $50 or more for it.

10-29-2001, 11:37 PM

I have both discs, though I also hate having to buy two versions unless one's a clear upgrade.

MGM's version has better picture by far. The sound I think is about even, though I respect the opinions of the reviewers here who say the Criterion is better.

The doc is great, but I kept my Criterion disc for the commentary (as well as some of the different features).

If you're only going to watch the movie, I'd say you'd be OK with the MGM disc - the better A/V wise, with ease of accessability and a nice doc, to boot. But if you've got the Criterion one already, don't pitch it if you buy the MGM disc.

bigdaddyhorse · 10-30-2001, 02:21 AM

The MGM has a better picture, 5.1 sound, and alot more deleted scenes. The new doc. is also excellent.
The Criterion has an awesome commentary track, one of the best pieced together tracks I've heard. Plus the serial killer essays are a great touch.
I recommend both.

10-28-2001, 10:32 PM	#1
TobalRox HackMaster Join Date: Sep 1999 Location: Springfield, MA Posts: 1,892	Silence of the Lambs CC vs. MGM Just curious as to what some of the differences were. I looked at hte back and it seemed pretty identical, but I read somewhere that they were different deleted scenes and commentaries. Just curious as to whether or not I should get the MGM. Oh, and another thing, anamorphic doesn't really mean anything to me right now since i don't have a 16x9 TV __________________ "It's a spadoinkle day" -Cannibal: The Musical Self proclaimed owner of oldest sig on the board! AIM: XnocreativityX My eBay auctions <-- Check often, as I am constantly adding new stuff

10-28-2001, 10:52 PM	#2
Dave Pimp Join Date: Sep 1999 Location: Newton, NH Posts: 6,188	Here are MY thoughts on this [ sorry, Paff! ]: When MGM announced this special edition, the question on everyone's mind was, "Should I still keep my Criterion disc?" True fans will actually want BOTH copies. The MGM version does provide a superior picture, and the documentaries are required viewing. But everyone should still locate the Criterion release if only for the commentary, as well as the serial killer essays on that disc. And I can attest that the Criterion laserdisc does have better sound. The bottom line is that it doesn't hurt to have more than one version of certain movies, and The Silence of the Lambs is one of the best. Get this disc. __________________ Horror Digital Amazon Link

10-28-2001, 11:17 PM	#3
TobalRox HackMaster Join Date: Sep 1999 Location: Springfield, MA Posts: 1,892	I forgot to mention that I already have the Criterion... I just hate having two copies of movies... I did it with AoD but that was just because I missed out on the 2 disc set. Man, now that' sjust more money I gotta spend... damn DVDs thanks for the info. __________________ "It's a spadoinkle day" -Cannibal: The Musical Self proclaimed owner of oldest sig on the board! AIM: XnocreativityX My eBay auctions <-- Check often, as I am constantly adding new stuff

10-29-2001, 11:37 PM	#6
AceRimRat Guest Posts: n/a	Both! I have both discs, though I also hate having to buy two versions unless one's a clear upgrade. MGM's version has better picture by far. The sound I think is about even, though I respect the opinions of the reviewers here who say the Criterion is better. The doc is great, but I kept my Criterion disc for the commentary (as well as some of the different features). If you're only going to watch the movie, I'd say you'd be OK with the MGM disc - the better A/V wise, with ease of accessability and a nice doc, to boot. But if you've got the Criterion one already, don't pitch it if you buy the MGM disc.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

10-29-2001, 07:16 PM	#5
KillerCannabis Slow, Deep & Hard Join Date: Oct 2000 Location: So Cal Posts: 5,606	I've got both versions of the film and I'd have to agree with the general consensus that if you're a fan of the film, you'll want both versions. The MGM disc will obviously be asy to find, however, the Criterion version is long out of print and could take some digging to find it. Maybe want to try e-bay, but youll probably end up paying $50 or more for it.

10-30-2001, 02:21 AM	#7
bigdaddyhorse Detroit Hi-on Join Date: Oct 2001 Location: Under a rock Posts: 11,957	The MGM has a better picture, 5.1 sound, and alot more deleted scenes. The new doc. is also excellent. The Criterion has an awesome commentary track, one of the best pieced together tracks I've heard. Plus the serial killer essays are a great touch. I recommend both.