Horror Digital  

Go Back   Horror Digital > Reviews > DVD Reviews A-M

Latest Poll
What do you think of the upcoming Phantasm Ravager?
This poll is closed
Looks great! Love seeing all the old cast back. 17 27%
Could be good, looks like another Phantasm sequel. 14 23%
Jury's still out, not sure about new director. 20 32%
Too little, too late; looks like they're forcing this. 6 10%
This series should have stayed in OblIVion. 5 8%
Voters: 62 100%
Replies (10)
Who's Online
There are currently 11 members and 82 guests. Most users ever online was 799, 04-10-2006 at 08:37 PM.
booper71, bruce h, Buechlers_beard, CPT HOOK, Kim Bruun, Ptflea2, Suicide, vidjunkie, xeldritchx, youthief
 Thread Rating: 42 votes, 5.00 average.
Old 08-30-2008, 09:25 AM
Scored: 8
Views: 11,057
Child's Play: Chucky's 20th Birthday Edition

Reviewer: Rhett
Review Date: August 30, 2008

Released by: MGM/Fox
Release date: 09/09/2008
MSRP: $14.98
Region 1, NTSC
Widescreen 1.78:1 | 16x9: Yes

People would slap you in the face if you tried to tell them that Childís Play, that movie with the killer doll, was actually a detective thriller. Indeed thatís how it was setup and conceived, thatís even the movie the lead, Catherine Hicks, thought she was making. It wasnít until the public got hold of it, and all the parallels with the equally inexplicable Cabbage Patch Doll craze, that Chucky was thrust front and center. The videocassette release proclaimed ďChucky did it!Ē with his freckled mug front and center on the cover. Itís no surprise, then, that the sequels abandoned the car chases and moody cityscapes to focus front and center on that red headed piece of plastic.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Itís been twenty years now (really?) and Chuckyís both a household name and a horror icon. Universalís made a habit of repackaging the sequels every other Halloween, but ever since Childís Play humbly made its way to DVD in 1999, thatís been it. Barebones and full frame, the debut of one of horrorís biggest names has been quietly neglected by United Artists. Finally though, Charles strolls into special edition thanks to Foxís partnership with MGM. Itís now time, once more, to revisit that moody street drama that just happens to have an animatronic doll in it. Letís give Childís a play.

The Story

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Chucky runs around terrorizing people, right? Well, yes and no. Youíll have to wait for that. First we get a cop chase through downtown Chicago. Frizzy-haired and armed, Charles Lee Ray (Brad Dourif) runs through slummy streets in a bid to lose detective Mike Norris (Chris Sarandon), whoís hot on his trail. Ray ends up breaking into a toy store, but heís no match for sharp shooter Norris. Norris shoots and scores, leaving Ray in desperation for his final breaths. He falls into a giant stack of Good Guys dolls, and with a little creativity and some black magic, transports his soul into the doll moments before being shot dead. Clouds form above and lightning strikes, but this Frankenstein is a whole lot smaller than youíd think.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Okay, now Chuckyís gonna rip shit up, right? Enter Karen Barclay (Catherine Hicks), a well to do single mother just trying to make ends meet in the big city. Sheís got a good friend beside her to stick through all the hardship she faces at her job between overtime and an uncompromising boss. Itís the birthday of her son Andy (Alex Vincent), and if thereís one thing in the world he wants, itís a Good Guys doll. Of course, theyíre all sold out, but lucky for her thereís a homeless guy behind the perfume shop with one carefully placed in his shopping cart. She gets aÖkiller deal on it, and instantly the dollís a huge hit with Andy. Too big of a hit, perhaps. Andy starts talking to Chucky as if he were real, and Karen and her friends start to wonder if Andyís compensating for his lack of a father figure. Then, all of a sudden, Karenís friend turns up dead.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Oh yeah, Chuckyís got it going now. Nope. Norris is brought in to investigate and immediately suspects Andy for the accidental apartment plunge. Sigh. It isnít until the half way mark that Chucky finally outs himself to the audience, blowing up the crack house of an unfaithful colleague. Norris continues to play detective, meanwhile, and Karen continues to cry her way to Oscar acclaim. Still though, Chucky trudges on, and while the body count may be feeble for slashers, for a doll itís not that bad. Chucky doesnít want to kill Andy, though, he wants to swap bodies. Will Charles Lee Ray thrive once more, or will Crockett, err, Norris, make his day?

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Childís Play is one of those weird movies, like Friday the 13th before it, that didnít understand its main draw until the sequels. Itís because of this that itís both parts puzzling and subtle. Puzzling in its reliance on bombastic action set pieces, with exploding stores, imploding houses, slow motion stunts and lengthy car chases and subtle in the way it slowly develops Chucky into the menace he is at the finale. Of course the latter seems more an oversight now, since they underestimated Chuckyís popularity in favor of appealing to adults with more action-oriented plotting. Considering how Chucky is front and center in the slasher formula of the sequels, all the action and family drama in Childís Play makes for interesting viewing.

Since the film thinks itself more a detective thriller than a horror film, the cinematography is disappointingly generic in the typical realist aesthetic that defined most cop movies of the era from Bronson to Seagal. This works okay for the inner-city stuff, but once we get a doll creeping around bedposts and being lit on fire, the look doesnít really know what to do with itself.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Director Tom Holland (Fright Night) seems as equally confused about his storytelling in the way he teeters between questioning Andyís sanity and playing on the dramatic irony of the audience knowing Chuckyís the killer when nobody else does. Itís pretty obvious from the opening ritual that the doll is possessed, but Holland takes great lengths to try to deny that fact to the audience. Andy talks to Chucky on screen, but Chucky doesnít talk back. The camera zooms in on Chuckyís doll eyes for a response, but nothing happens. Karenís friend gets a hammer to the face, but those look like Andyís footprints. Now, the original ďBlood BuddyĒ script reputedly played out the question of Andyís sanity since it did not have the possessive elements of the introduction. A few re-writes later though, it comes off as confused and ill-conceived, like Holland wasted 45-minutes on a revelation that was obvious from the introduction.

Writer Don Mancini has always been quick to state how he intended the film as a subtle satire of the capitalistic Cabbage Patch Kids craze, but why then does the film slovenly conform to those same capitalistic values? Having Hicks buy the doll from a homeless man on the black market works as some sort of reinforcement for big business Ė go outside the system and the results could be deadly. By horror movie logic, thatís grounds for punishment. What would have been much more effective, and subversive, would be if she would have bought the doll right off the shelf of your average department store. For to do that would suggest that everyone is the victim when it comes to hype, not just the people conforming illegally.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

The finale is similarly frustrating in that at first it seems progressive, with the tough guy cop rendered immobile in the bedroom, while mother and son fend off the villain. It says something about the power of the family unit, how, with love and trust, that patriarch is not needed to make the system complete. But when it comes time to finally kill Chucky for the last time, Holland leaves it stereotypically for the guy with the gun. For a movie able to think broadly enough to bring a doll to life, youíd think theyíd be able to think outside the box when it came to social values, plot and cinematography.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

Iím being hard on the little firecrotch, though. Brad Dourif makes for a truly menacing presence even off-screen and coupled with the amazing animatronic work by Kevin Yagher and co., Chuckyís truly a childhood nightmare come to life. Alex Vincent deserves equal praise for his performance as Andy Ė truly one of the best child performances in the genre, convincing at every turn and, in that monumental correctional facility breakdown, even heart wrenching. Thereís no wonder why they brought him back over the scene-chewing Hicks. Before the patriarchy police kick in at the end, the finale too deserves kudos for really piling on the intensity. Thereís some great, tense moments there.

All in all, though, Childís Play is a ho hum action drama with a great horror villain waiting in the wings. Itís a long wait for the killer doll goods, and even when Chuckyís unleashed the film seems more interested in dramatic irony than mining scares. Thereís no question that Chucky is a classic horror character, but is Childís Play a classic horror film? No way.

Image Quality

Itís been nine years since Chuckyís been in the telecine, and the good news is that now heís finally anamorphic. The previous MGM transfer was open matte, and while this is definitely preferable to pan and scan, it left compositions too loose and vacant. Considering how uninspired the cinematography is, believe me, the tighter the better. The tighter framing actually works quite well for the finale, isolating those close-ups of Chuckyís rotting face or Andyís scared eyes to their bare essentials.

inline Image inline Image
1999 DVD

The bad news, is that aside from the extra bit of resolution offered by anamorphic enhancement, this transfer isnít all that different from the previous. Colors are slightly more realistic, you can see this in the peach coloring of the skin as opposed to the red that shows up occasionally in the previous transfer. Same thing too with the blues, with the big city looking much more flattering in the new mix. Thereís a bit more detail too, evident in the shot of Chuckyís eye emerging from the smoke, but again, itís only a minor improvement. There are still some scenes here that look quite grainy, and black levels never seem to be deep enough.

Make no mistake, itís a nice upgrade and definitely a deal sealer for those who donít yet own the film, but after seeing how far the transfer business has come in the last nine years, it canít help but feel a little underwhelming.


The sound gets a new upgrade with a Dolby Digital 5.1 track, but keeps the original 2.0 track for the purists. This new mix is like the video, a modest improvement, but nothing really to write home about. Thereís still the directional separation between the left and right, but youíll have to listen long and hard to find any movement in the rear speakers. The bass gets a decent workout during all those bombastic chase and explosion scenes, and the climax has a decent bit of punch at the end, but overall it feels more like a 2.1 track than it does full our five channel.

Supplemental Material

inline ImageI had a blast with all the inventive extras that came with Seed of Chucky, and while this new special edition is nowhere near as clever, it still definitely delivers the goods. Thereís no shortage of supplements Ė three commentaries, six featurettes, and a bunch of promo material, but even with all this the extras never get repetitive. Don Mancini and producer David Kirschner start things off with energy with their group commentary. Thereís a lot of laughs and a lot of information, with Mancini filled with funny observations, impressive film knowledge and a number of solid questions that fuels Kirschner for the bits that heís not talking. The next commentary with actors Alex Vincent and Catherine Hicks as well as Hickís husband, and the man behind the doll, Kevin Yagher. Yagher and Hicks were naturally recorded together, but Vincent was separate, and the two tracks have been edited together quite effectively. Itís really nice hearing from Vincent, since child actors tend to get overlooked when it comes to supplements these days. The good thing is that Vincent really remembers a lot, and really has a lot to say. Hicks and Yagher have fun together, and the three different vantage points on the making of the film really make for another informative track.

The last commentary is more of a joke, with Brad Dourif in character as Chucky commenting on four select scenes. Itís a fun continuation of the character, even if itís sort of one note. He talks on everything from the film business to murder, so in a way itís a nice continuation of Seed of Chucky. Too bad the series is going into remake mode now, though.

inline ImageOn to the featurettes, thereís three new ones packaged together that look at the film from pre-production, production and finally its legacy. Each one runs around six minutes, and features interviews with all the commentary participants as well as Chris Sarandon and a number of other crew members. The noticeable exclude is Tom Holland. Note to Fox: Getting the director for extras might be a good idea. Still, Mancini is without a doubt the father of this franchise, so not having Holland is not a total loss. Each of the three featurettes are well edited (maybe a bit too edited) and basically a nice abridged version of the commentaries.

inline ImageThe ďChucky: Building a NightmareĒ featurette looks at all the effects work used to bring Chucky to life. Thereís some great vintage footage of Yagher and co. on set 20 years ago, and even some new insight from Tom Savini. It runs under ten minutes and thanks to Yagherís open book insight to the craft and all the behind-the-scenes footage, itís another great look. The last of the new supplements is ďMonster ConventionĒ, which is a five minute Q&A at a fan convention with Alex Vincent, Chris Sarandon and Catherine Hicks. Convention extras are often my favorite, since nobody knows the questions the fans want answered more than the fans, and this one doesnít disappoint. Itís a little short, but still, definitely interesting.

inline ImageThereís also a vintage featurette, ďIntroducing Chucky: The Making of Childís PlayĒ that runs about six minutes and is more effects focused than your typical EPK. Tom Holland starts it off with his take on the story, and David Kirschner also weighs in with an impressive eighties beard and mullet. Itís sort of dry and predictable, but a nice vintage look at how movies like this were sold back then. The other promotional materials youíd expect Ė a photo gallery and the trailer, are also included, in addition to a few trailers for other current Universal horror flicks. Those who dig will also find three eye opening easter eggs. All I can say is if they go that route for Chucky in the remake, I'll probably cry.

Thereís a lot of supplements to wade through here, but thankfully itís all worth it. On their work on the supplements, Iíve got to sayÖGood Guys.

Final Thoughts

Childís Play is an interesting start for our little killer doll icon, not because itís a great film, but more because itís not the one youíd expect. Itís more a cop drama that only finds its successful horror footing for the perfectly puppetted climax. The rest is more average than anything. The video and audio restorations here are at least slightly above average, but arenít quite the leap one would expect in this day of digital restoration. The supplements though, are a real treat, with information and entertainment hand in hand throughout. The makers of these Chucky films always have so much to talk about Ė Universal, special editions for Childís Play 2 and Childís Play 3 are calling out to you! Chuckyís a horror staple, and even if the film isnít quite worthy of the legend, this is a disc that all horror fans should have in their collection for historical purpose alone. Happy birthday, Chucky!


Movie - B-

Image Quality - B

Sound - B+

Supplements - A-

Technical Info.
  • Color
  • Running time - 1 hour and 27 minutes
  • Rated R
  • 1 Disc
  • Chapter Stops
  • English Dolby Digital 5.1
  • English Dolby Surround 2.0
  • Spanish Dolby Surround 2.0
  • French Dolby Surround 2.0
  • French subtitles
  • French subtitles

  • 3 audio commentaries
  • 5 new featurettes
  • 1 vintage featurette
  • Theatrical trailer
  • Universal trailers
  • Still gallery
  • Easter eggs


Can't argue with a confident man.

New Article
New Reply

DVD Reviews A-M
« Previous | Next »

Old 08-30-2008, 02:52 PM
Did you find the 3 easter eggs?
PSN: Marvdogger
Old 08-30-2008, 07:01 PM
Yeah, the eggs were a nice touch, although it just has me fearing what's going to happen for the CHILD'S PLAY remake.
Can't argue with a confident man.
Old 09-01-2008, 10:58 AM
I don't know...

I always found the first one to be the best...

I mean, it had some amazing set pieces and some classic scenes.

Each sequel just got dumber.
Old 09-01-2008, 03:05 PM
I agree, the Army one made me want to puke and don't get me going on John freaking Ritter!
"And Darkness and Decay and the Red Death held illimitable dominion over all"

-EAP Masque of the Red Death
Old 09-02-2008, 01:42 AM
I'm glad this one is finally getting a decent DVD release. The first 2 in the series were by far the best, with the later films going the way of the NOES series by becoming more humorous than scary.

Posting Rules
You may not post new articles
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Main > Reviews > DVD Reviews A-M
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:56 PM.

Portal By vbPortal Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, vbPortal. All Rights Reserved.