Horror Digital  

Go Back   Horror Digital > Reviews > Hi-Def Reviews

Latest Poll
Best 5th Film in a Horror Franchise?
A Nightmare on Elm Street Part 5: The Dream Child
Children of the Corn V: Fields of Terror
Diary of the Dead
Final Destination 5
Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed
Friday the 13th, Part V: A New Beginning
Halloween 5
Hellraiser: Inferno
Howling V: The Rebirth
Leprechaun in the Hood
Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones
Resident Evil: Retribution
Return to Sleepaway Camp
Saw V
Seed of Chucky
Silent Night, Deadly Night 5: The Toy Maker
Taste the Blood of Dracula
Texas Chainsaw 3D
The Amityville Curse
The Mummy's Curse
Who's Online
There are currently 8 members and 79 guests. Most users ever online was 799, 04-10-2006 at 07:37 PM.
17thJuggalo, Anaestheus, buck135, maybrick, Mikey Horror, MrTransistor1, Steel76
 Thread Rating: 5 votes, 5.00 average.
Old 10-31-2010, 07:56 PM
Stalker
 
Scored: 7
Views: 7,826
Halloween II (2009), Director's Cut




Reviewer: Chunkblower
Review Date: October 31, 2010

Format: Blu-ray
Released by: Sony
Release date: January 12, 2010
MSRP: $24.95
Region All Region
Progressive Scan
Codec: AVC, 1080p
Widescreen 1.85 | 16x9: Yes
2009




inline ImageRemakes are already a dicey prospect but Rob Zombie’s Halloween was arguably one of the most contentious projects of the last decade’s slew of remakes. Some people found his unique vision a clever reinvention of a mouldy old story, while many purists thought it was a desecration of a scared relic. I kind of split the difference; while there were fantastic elements, it was also unforgivably mean-spirited and self-indulgent. It was also the highest grossing film in the series (not inflation adjusted – the original 1978 film has still sold the most tickets), guaranteeing a sequel would follow. While 2007’s Halloween was controversial and divisive amongst fans of the series, the second film would be even more so but for entirely different reasons.


The Story

inline ImageIt is mere minutes after Laurie Strode (Scout Taylor Compton) pulled the trigger of the gun that supposedly killed Michael Myers (Tyler Mane). She wanders the streets of Haddonfield, bloodied, dazed and babbling to herself. She’s found by Sheriff Leigh Brackett (Brad Dourif) and rushed to the emergency room. Meanwhile, Michael’s body is hauled to the morgue by two sleazy coroners (Dayton Callie and Richard Brake). En route the van gets in an accident and the supposedly dead Michael is freed. Meanwhile, at the hospital, Laurie has nightmares about being stalked by Michael in the hospital.

inline ImageFlash forward two years. Laurie is living with the Bracketts, all of whom bare scars beyond the physical. Laurie is attending therapy session with a psychologist (Margot Kidder), but the healing process is not going smoothly. She has fallen in with a new clique of friends and is becoming ever more estranged from Annie (Danielle Harris) and Leigh. Meanwhile, Dr. Loomis (Malcolm McDowell), more arrogant and self-absorbed than ever, has written a book about the events of the first film, a book which contains revelations about Laurie’s past that Leigh has tried to shelter her from. When she reads it Laurie is driven into a rage and, when she runs off to numb the pain with partying and alcohol, Michael returns to Haddonfield to finish what he started.

inline ImageI wasn’t the biggest fan of Rob Zombie’s first two films and approached his remake with a great degree of trepidation. While the sequels had certainly gone to the well a few times too many and a remake was really the only viable way to continue the franchise, I thought that there couldn’t possibly be a person less qualified to reinvent the series than Rob Zombie. Zombie is an odd case as a filmmaker: he’s obviously got chops behind the camera but his movies are mired in such aggressive unpleasantness and misogyny that I’m torn between praising the effectiveness of his individual set pieces while still finding his films repellent and sleazy, as well as over indulgent. The beginning of the Halloween remake didn’t exactly instil confidence: while it was most assuredly the work of an auteur, it was pretty clear the Zombie either missed or totally didn’t care about what made the original so special. I enjoyed the second half’s truncated version of Carpenter’s film, but again I was torn. It was pretty clearly imposed on Zombie by the studio and it was unfortunate that he couldn’t realize his true vision even if that wasn’t a vision I was interested in sharing.

inline ImageBy his own admission, after finishing the first film Zombie was done with the Halloween universe. Producers hungry to recreate the success of the first film found a way to get Rob back on board, probably money and the promise of creative freedom. It’s pretty clear from frame one that he was given more leeway to make a film more in line with his own personal vision. It’s still a cynical rush job from a filmmaker who had no interest in making it but was given money and creative freedom, an irresistible carrot in Hollywood. It is also, moment to moment, better than the remake.

inline ImagePerhaps it would take the misfire that was Rob Zombie’s Halloween to truly prepare me to appreciate his sequel. Whatever flaws his first foray to Haddonfield had, Zombie was successful in doing the things he needed to do: to establish a new universe, the characters that inhabit it and the tone the series would take. With that grounding, I found it a lot easier to get into Zombie’s Haddonfield the second time around. It was less grating since there were no scenes that invited direct comparison to 1981’s Halloween II. Rob Zombie’s Halloween II is his best film to date, a major improvement over the first Halloween and very nearly a fantastic movie in its own right.

inline ImageAfter the overlong, but brutally effective, opening sequence the film settles into its story. There are three separate plots that nominally connect at the end of the film. There’s Laurie and the Bracketts dealing with the aftermath of the first film, Loomis and his assistant working the talk show circuit for a book tour and Michael’s slow return from…somewhere… to Haddonfield. Given the focus of the first film, it would be understandable for one to think that Zombie’s would pay the most attention to Michael’s story. Surprisingly, he doesn’t. Michael’s scenes seem utterly perfunctory, their inclusion an afterthought.

inline ImageThe largest and most developed section of the film deals with Laurie and her surrogate family dealing with the aftermath of their ordeal. During these scenes it’s actually a strong character study, with sympathetic characters having relatable problems and understandable reactions. Whereas Halloween played as part serial killer biopic and part Cliff’s Notes version of Carpenter’s original film, Halloween II is an entirely unique entity, both in the series and in Zombie’s canon. He shifts the focus of the film from the killers and freaks to relatively normal characters, albeit ones with a lot of baggage. Scout Taylor Compton, Danielle Harris and Brad Dourif all do solid work building the relationship of this surrogate family.

inline ImageLaurie’s post-traumatic stress is well established and convincingly developed, but Zombie doesn’t take the easy way out by making her a one-dimensional, put-upon victim. She’s selfish and self-absorbed and takes for granted the generosity and friendship of the Bracketts. In short, she’s a real, flawed, incredibly damaged but well fleshed out character. Laurie and Annie’s relationship is the single strongest element of Halloween II. They are two women united by a shared history and tragedy and it’s that tragedy that is the source of the widening rift between them. They are growing apart because of their coping mechanisms are so different. Both actresses give fantastic performances in the scenes where their relationship is allowed to take centre stage. There’s a fantastic scene where Annie gives Laurie a total dressing down and pulls no punches. It’s a raw, sad scene that speaks with real human truth; something I thought was completely beyond Zombie’s capabilities. This dynamic lends Annie’s final scene a surprising amount of power. The two female leads give Halloween II the emotional core that Zombie’s first Halloween lacked. This is the first time Zombie has shown an understanding of emotional truth. I’m surprised to say it, but Zombie actually allows the characters to show some humanity. Could this be a sign that he’s maturing as a writer? I shudder to think.

inline ImageBrad Dourif’s Leigh is also lot more nuanced than in the first film. He’s dealing with the guilt of not being able to protect his daughter or her friends, and projects a subtle sense of emasculation because of it. His work in the last act is magnificent. The only character arc that isn’t truly satisfying is Loomis’. With Loomis’ book signing and talk show scenes it appears like Zombie is taking a dig at his more ardent fans, but Loomis is such an unlikable bastard throughout that his 11th hour change of heart just doesn’t ring true. I’m sure Zombie got a kick out of turning Loomis into a total asshole and having him have nothing to do with the rest of the movie until the final five minutes, but I just found it a depressing waste of an awesome actor.

This is probably the type of story Zombie should be telling: he can have relatable characters while still sticking to his usual tropes. He identifies with the outcast and tries to make them the centre of every film, but it’s a lot easier for the audience to identify with someone trying to cope with survivors’ guilt than with a homicidal maniac or rapist. Even at her least sympathetic, Laurie is still far more likable than just about any other character in Zombie’s entire filmography.

inline Image There are some really fantastic scenes here and, even better, they contribute far more significantly to a larger narrative than any scenes in the first film did. For all its narrative improvements over the first film, Halloween II still often feels more like a collection of deleted scenes than an actual movie. Like Tarantino, Zombie ruthlessly pilfers from pop culture. He can craft intense scenes, and he even gets a modicum of suspense going here and there, but H2 is never at any point even remotely scary and, at 119 minutes, the director’s cut is way too long (the 101 minute theatrical version is better even if still too long). There’s a scene at the Rabbit in Red lounge which serves no purpose other than providing the film with its requisite doses of mutilation and misogyny.

inline ImageHalloween II was met with absolute derision in its theatrical release. I went to see it opening night with an audience of Goth kids and metalheads that could only be described as Zombie’s core audience. As the film went on, I could see their anxiousness increase and when it was over it is one of the few mainstream films I’ve attended that earned boos. As I write this, it’s sitting at a 4.9 aggregate score on IMDB, one the lowest for the series. Like the first Halloween, Zombie offers us a bill of goods then delivers something totally different. In this case, however, he gave us something better than advertised: a surprisingly strong character drama. Hopefully audience dissatisfaction will fade with time and Halloween II will be rediscovered in a few years and get the credit it deserves as a fascinating, if not wholly successful, entry into the Halloween canon.


Image Quality

Halloween II was shot on 16mm and blown up to 35mm. As expected, this results in a film that is loaded with grain. It’s a completely conscious aesthetic choice by Zombie but it makes evaluating the picture quality a bit difficult. Do I give it high marks for being a good representation of Zombie’s aesthetic, or do I dock it points for its muddy look, intentional or not?

inline ImageGrain is always very active, but never more so than in dark scenes. It makes detail in the image hard to discern. This is further exacerbated by the decision to shoot with a lot of fog, smoke and filters. There are occasional scenes that look a bit less grainy; this might be an indication that some noise reduction filter was applied to the transfer. Some shots, like the close up of Loomis during a speech, show the kind of sharpness, detail and contrast that you’d expect from a 1080p transfer. Zombie’s colour palette is muted by design, though there are still bold colours occasionally on display (see the party, or at the Rabbit in Red lounge). The scenes added back into the film proper for the director’s cut don’t show the use contrast changes that mar so many extended cuts.

Sound

inline ImageThe English 5.1 DTS-HD track is not as active or aggressive as the one found on the Halloween Blu-ray, but it’s still fairly strong. That’s probably partly due to the fact that, after the prologue, Halloween II is more dialogue oriented than the first film. The surrounds are active with sound effects (check out the rain storm or the car crash at the beginning), but there’s not much in the way of panning effects. Dialogue is never difficult to discern but that may have something to do with the fact that most of it is shouted.

Supplemental Material

inline ImageFirst up is the usual exorbitant collection of Deleted Scenes (25:14). Unlike the first disc, though, there’s no commentary to give the scenes context or explain why the scenes were cut. Zombie’s decisions in this regard seem pretty arbitrary: any number of scenes in this collection could be swapped with scenes from the movie without significantly changing the overall experience. There is one really good scene between Mya and Laurie before they find Annie that was probably cut because Zombie felt it was overstating the obvious, but I think it actually would have made an already powerful scene even better and added a bit of suspense to the last act of the film.

There’s a Blooper Reel (4:26) that’s not nearly as funny as the one for Halloween, probably due to the fact that Leigh and Loomis had very few scenes together so McDowell and Dourif didn’t have the chance to ham it up. On his own, McDowell seems a bit crusty and on edge. I guess you had to be there.

inline ImageMore Audition Footage (9:37) is again included. Zombie certainly has an eye for talent even if he’s not always able to best utilize that talent on screen. I found this collection of scenes gave me a greater appreciation for the actors since they’re selling their performances outside of the environment of the set. Chase Wright Vanek actually gave me chills at one point. I can’t tell if Angela Trimbur was acting or just being herself but if she was acting, then she’s simply amazing. This feature is a good length and doesn’t overstay its welcome.

There’s some Make Up Test Footage (3:35) included. Nothing special here.

Extended versions of Uncle Seymour Coffin’s Stand Up Routines (8:40) have lousy location audio, which I guess doesn’t matter much considering the material. I’m not sure if his jokes are supposed to be of the “so bad it’s good” variety. They mostly just suck. The footage does boast extra nudity for those interested, and he reads a letter from “Malek,” perhaps in reference to Malek Akkad?

Music videos from Captain Clegg and the Night Creatures (19:11) are your usual produced for DVD videos that blend low production value footage of the band with clips taken from the movie. While not the best horrorbilly music ever (a bit too much emphasis on the “billy” for my tastes), it’s nonetheless fun music to listen to, although you’d be better off just putting the music on your iPod.

inline ImageWriter/Director Rob Zombie provides another Audio Commentary. With his articulate, soft spoken tone you’d think he was commentating on an Oscar bait drama. The shoot for Halloween II seems like it was absolutely hellish, with Zombie and his crew having to contend with rain, footage lost to and from the lab as well as studio-ordered reshoots. Zombie’s engaging as usual but he sounds like he’s really unhappy with the finished film, even though it’s his director’s cut. There’s an odd moment during Mya’s death where the commentary cuts out nearly midsentence for a couple of seconds before Zombie resumes talking. I’m not sure if this constitutes a technical glitch or studio censorship?

Lastly is the BD Live Movie IQ feature. When activated, an information box pops up at the beginning of each new scene detailing IMDB type info – cast, crew, music, etc. Seems kind of pointless to me, but if you’re the type of person who consults IMDB 20 times on your iPhone while watching a movie, it might be helpful.


Final Thoughts

inline ImageEven marred by Zombie’s usual excesses, Halloween II still feels leaner than the first and more of a piece. Instead of cramming two disparate halves uncomfortably together he tells an actual story that has a beginning, middle and an end, is populated with characters that are sympathetic and have motives we can understand, and even manages some truly intense set pieces along the way. It’s not a masterpiece but it’s a strong film and a totally worthy entry into the Halloween pantheon. Based solely on the strength of the movie, this Blu-ray release gets a mild recommendation despite lacking in presentation and supplements.

Rating

.
Movie - B

Image Quality - C+

Sound - B-

Supplements - B-





Technical Info.
  • Colour
  • Running time - 1 hour and 59 minutes
  • Not Rated
  • 1 Disc
  • Chapter Stops
  • English 5.1 DTS-HD
  • English SDH subtitles
  • English subtitles

Supplements
  • Deleted and Alternate Scenes
  • Audition Footage
  • Make-up Test Footage
  • Blooper Reel
  • Captain Clegg and the Night Creatures Music Videos
  • Commentary With Writer/Director Rob Zombie
  • Uncle Seymour Coffin’s Stand-up Routines

Back Cover

 


Last edited by Chunkblower; 10-31-2010 at 08:01 PM..
 

Extras
New Article
New Reply

Hi-Def Reviews
« Previous | Next »

Old 11-01-2010, 11:56 AM
Maniac
aggravating film, a swear-word contest in place of real dialogue, messily filmed scenes where you sometimes can't make out what's happening, a very unsympathetic Laurie Strode, ludicrous 'white horse' scenes,...

i was so glad that i hadn't bought the BluRay instead of my friend, we suffered together while watching this

if justice is served, this will be the very last film that Rob Zombie will EVER direct or participate in
 
 
Old 11-01-2010, 04:47 PM
No Avatar! Boo!
Nice to see some love/like for this film. I didn't go see this one in theaters because the first film wasn't anything spectacular and as a result got to hear the almost universal hatred toward this film being spewed by Halloween fans and casual observers.

I don't know. Maybe it's because of lowered expectations but I really liked this movie. I think Zombie does human tragedy quite well and he proves it with this movie. I found the story of Laurie and the Bracketts to be almost heart-breaking as they tried to deal with the aftermath of part 1. I honestly was hoping Michael would just leave them alone. Which I knew he wouldn't

Anyway, I enjoyed the review and it's nice to see that not everyone hated this movie. Personally I think this is the one that got me excited about what Mr. Zombie will do next. He has some potential after all.
__________________
Movie Tracker: 20132014
 
 
Old 11-01-2010, 06:05 PM
Stalker
Completely agree with hellraiser40's comment on this one.

Seen this a few nights ago and won't be watching it again. Watched the Original Part 2 last night again and I'll be sticking with that.
 
 
Old 11-01-2010, 07:14 PM
HackMaster
I love both of his Halloween films (not my favorite Zombie film, that honor goes to The Devil's Rejects) but I prefer H2. It's more of a Rob Zombie film and it feels very personal. It's gritty, emotional and extremey violent and the DC ending left more of an impact on this fanboy than the theatrical ending.
__________________
+6 trader.
Facebook. DVD Aficionado.
 
 
Old 11-01-2010, 11:08 PM
Maniac
Loathe this film. I can appreciate Zombie going his own direction and not redoing Halloween 2 like he did with Halloween, but this... is not a Halloween film at all. Everyone save for Annie is repulsive, misogynistic and angry at the world.

There was some human tragedy done well (and the end scene is so out of place it's hilarious), but compared to the utterly wretched script and acting it's a gold speck in a tub of shit. And don't get me started on the Rabbit in the Red Lounge scene, it was both stunningly awful and brutally violent.
 
 
Old 11-02-2010, 02:05 AM
Don't Monkey With Me!
I saw this for the first time a couple of weeks back and have to say it is one of the biggest pieces of shit I've ever seen!
 
 
Old 11-02-2010, 04:18 AM
Screamy Bopper
I never thought I'd be defending a Rob Zombie movie (since I DETEST Devil's Rejects) but I saw this last year in the theaters with my friends and had a great time, and in a way it reminded me of the bad-trippy Halloween party we had a couple of days before, hehe. Watching Laurie's drunken downfall is painful, and the opening sequence is scary as hell. The girl is just trying to get over her f*cked up past but Michael just won't let her go. It all felt very real, since not so often we have the chance to see the trauma of slashers' survivors so closely. (Also loved the Rocky Horror costumes, btw)
__________________
"Hey, somebody get some light over here, Trash is taking off her clothes again."
 
 

Posting Rules
You may not post new articles
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Main > Reviews > Hi-Def Reviews
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:21 PM.


Portal By vbPortal Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vbPortal. All Rights Reserved.